Tuesday, February 03, 2009

Boy Who Cried Wolf

Among our practice, there are a group of patient's who we refer to as frequent fliers. They are folks who wind up in the ER on such a regular basis, that we all know them well. Some, unfortunately, have medical problems that are resistant to outpatient control. Despite their best efforts and ours, they just keep bouncing back.

Then there are the GOMERS. Aptly named by the book "House of God", a GOMER is a 'get out of my ER'. It doesn't sound very charitable, but believe me.

These are patient's who mix in a lot of crazy with a little bit of illness and know how to work the system. They usually come in with the same complaints that can't be objectively proven and are often attached to some secondary gain. When the ER calls us to say that 'miss cyclical vomiting syndrome' is back again, there is much eye rolling to be had. If anyone had ever seen her vomit, or had evidence that she was in need of anything except more narcotics, there wouldn't be such a reaction.

But I got to thinking today: It's a dangerous game, this letting ourselves roll our eyes at the patient's we've come to expect melodramatic reporting from.

I got a call on a patient of mine who was back in the ER with the same pain complaints she has always had. The ER is so tired of her coming in for this, that they barely even initiate a work-up before giving her massive doses of pain meds. I walked in to her room with a pre-conceived notion of what she would say and need. And, for the most part, I was right.

Except there was one new symptom that she brought up. Could be part of her previous syndrome, I thought. Could be something new. I stopped. 'What would I do if I'd never met her before? What would I order if I had no idea her history of coming back again and again with these symptoms?"

It changed my management. I'm not sure if anything will come of it, but it was a humbling moment. Usually continuity is the thing that makes good medicine tick. But every once in a while, the past only obscures our view of the present.

In our friendships, in our work relationships, in our families, we've all come to expect certain things from certain people. But sometimes, we need to let that go. We need to believe that people innately have the ability to surprise us, and leave our doors open to be receptive to that.

Because at some point, we're all going to be the one asking for belief and a chance. And we all deserve to be heard.

The Girl Who Would Never Cry Wolf. Seriously.

9 comments:

Lyndsey said...

I have a good friend that is a PA and spend a year or 2 in the ER in downtown LA and she always had some seriously crazy stories about the regulars. I think that medical system is flawed. Miss you guys!!

two forks said...

okay your chickadee is too cute!

MwH said...

I love this post! Funny and thoughtful. And the darling pic at the end puts it in the perfect 10 category. love you.

LauraJ said...

I love your stories Kate - you are the best!

Baby E is adorable - totally a darling! Hope all is well with you guys.

Lisa Michelle said...

Ok, that picture is AWESOME. Lovin' the shades! And it was nice to read your thoughts tonight -- had an interesting night with some 8-11 year-olds at church and this was a good reminder to sometimes forget how they always act and hope for change (at least sometime in the next 10 years...!).

Sara Gibson said...

I think GOMER is the funniest name. I can't imagine wanting to go to the ER on a regular basis. No thanks. I love your insight, and your stories are wonderful to read. After reading this one I realized that there are definitely people that will call me that I automatically think, 'here we go again' and that is not being a good friend. So, thanks for the reminder.

Eva is so beyond cute.

Lynda said...

Good for you Kate. Everybody should read "How Doctors Think" by Jerome Groopman. It's so easy for doctors and everybody else for that matter, to fall into the trap of pre-conceptions, of deciding before all the evidence is in, of not really listening, of eye-rolling taking the place of empathy. You're one of the great ones. (No prejudices here.)

scrapperjen said...

Very good post - good "food for thought". I always like your stories! Thanks!
And Miss E - very chic!

Mary and Jared said...

Interesting post. As a statistician, I always think that physicians are Bayesians in nature. That means that they are trying to find just one similar case and do what worked there. All medical testing is based on treating the average patient (whatever that means). But I don't think physicians think that way. Which means there are a lot of interesting points of intersection between "proven" treatments (drugs, devices, procedures, etc) and how physicians actually work.

If you want to read an intersting book about suggestions for changing the current health care situation, you should pick up "The Innovator's Prescription." It is by Clayton Christensen, Jerome Grossman, and Jason Hwang. It is fascinating.